Magnesium Supplements
February 22, 2010 Written by JP
[Download PDF]
[Font too small?]
One of the most frequent questions I’m asked has do with which supplements are the most essential. Many people who inquire are already taking a multivitamin. It’s not always the best multivitamin, but at least it provides the basic nutrients that are often lacking in the modern diet. However, there are certain minerals that are never provided in adequate amounts in a standard one-a-day supplement. They’re simply too bulky to be contained in a single capsule or even a large tablet.

Two minerals fall into this category: calcium and magnesium. This is why doctors will regularly ask patients to take a calcium supplement in addition to a multivitamin. Many calcium products include some added Vitamin D to facilitate calcium absorption and retention. But it’s rather uncommon for non-health food store supplements to contain substantial amounts of magnesium as well.
In my opinion, the current view of calcium and magnesium is a bit off kilter. Calcium is quite easy to obtain by eating foods that are fortified with it. On the other hand, magnesium generally flies under the radar of most dietitians and commercial food manufacturers. This is a shame because the potential of this element is quite impressive indeed. Here are five examples that illustrate some of the reasons why I think you should keep this mineral in your cross hairs.
Magnesium Supports Lung Function - A new study published in the Journal of Asthma examined the effects of supplementing with magnesium over a six month period. Researchers from Bastyr University in Washington State enrolled 55 adult patients with mild-to-moderate asthma into a double blind, placebo controlled trial. Half of the participants were given a placebo and the treatment group received 340 milligrams (170 mg twice daily) of magnesium per day. By the end of the experiment, those receiving the supplemental magnesium exhibited a 5.8% enhancement of lung function as measured by “peak expiratory flow rate”. This same group proved to be 20% more resistant to chemically induced constriction of the lungs. The magnesium test subjects also noted a subjective improvement in quality of life. None of these benefits were similarly reported by the placebo patients. The lead researcher of the trial, Dr. Alexandra Kazaks, suggests that magnesium may assist the expansion of the lungs through anti-inflammatory activity and positively influencing cell membranes. (1)
Magnesium Supports Healthier Pregnancies - The February 2010 issue of the journal Biological Trace Element Research puts the spotlight on pre-eclampsia, “the most common medical complication of pregnancy associated with increased maternal and infant mortality and morbidity”. Fifty expectant mothers with either mild or severe pre-eclampsia (pregnancy induced high blood pressure) and 50 healthy expectant mothers had their serum calcium, magnesium and zinc concentrations analyzed. Here’s what the test results revealed:
- Healthy Pregnant Women - Calcium: 2.45 mmol/L; Magnesium: .79 mmol/L; Zinc: 15.64 micromol/L
- Mildly Pre-Eclamptic Women - Calcium: 2.12 mmol/L; Magnesium: .67 mmol/L; Zinc: 12.72 micromol/L
- Severly Pre-Eclamptic Women - Calcium: 1.94 mmol/L; Magnesium: .62 mmol/L; Zinc: 12.04 micromol/L
The authors of the study made the following comment: “These results indicate that reductions in serum levels of calcium, magnesium, and zinc during pregnancy might be possible contributors in the etiology of pre-eclampsia, and supplementation of these elements to diet may be of value to prevent pre-eclampsia”. (2,3)
Magnesium Supports Bone Mineral Density - A recent Turkish study set out to determine why magnesium appears to strengthen bones. Twenty postmenopausal women took part in a 30 day trial in which half supplemented with 1,830 mg of magnesium citrate (about 200 mg of actual magnesium) or a placebo. Blood urine samples were taken at the start of the trial and on days 5, 10, 20 and 30. The female volunteers in the magnesium group showed significant decreases in deoxypyridinoline and serum parathyroid hormone levels and an increase in osteocalcin concentrations. The researchers conducting the study concluded that “oral magnesium supplementation in postmenopausal osteoporotic women suppresses bone tunover”. Individuals who have a high bone turnover rate are at an increased risk for bone loss and osteoporosis. (4)

Magnesium Supports Mental Health - Scientists at St. Paul’s Hospital in Seoul, Korea have recently uncovered a link between mineral status and mental health. The discovery came about while comparing blood levels of calcium and magnesium in a group of 112 women recruited from an outpatient clinic. An assessment was made about the participants degree of anxiety, depression and stress based on the results of two standardized questionnaires: “the Hospital Anxiety Depression Scale and the Modified Brief Encounter Psychosocial Instrument Stress Scale”. The researchers looked for patterns between mineral status and the severity of psychological distress. They determined that those with the lowest levels of magnesium were at greater risk for “depressive mood disorder”. Having too high a concentration of calcium and too low a level of magnesium (Ca/Mg ratio) correlated with greater depression and stress scores as well. Theoretically, this type of imbalance could be rather common because of the relative abundance of calcium in the 21st century diet. It’s also interesting to note that stressful events have been documented as prompting an increased excretion of magnesium. (5,6,7)
Magnesium Supports Ocular Health - Magnesium citrate is a form of magnesium that is often utilized in clinical research because it’s highly absorbable. This particular mineral compound is produced by chemically bounding magnesium and citric acid - often referred to as a mineral chelate. A new report in the European Journal of Ophthalmology examined the effects of 300 mg of magnesium citrate on 15 patients suffering from “normotensive glaucoma” (NTG). Fifteen additional NTG patients were provided with an identical looking placebo for 30 days. Serum magnesium levels, a “color Doppler imaging of the orbital vessels” and a visual field test were conducted pre and post intervention. Those receiving the magnesium therapy exhibited improvements in visual field scores, but there was no detectable change in ocular blood flow. More studies are needed to clarify the exact mechanism by which magnesium improves vision in those with glaucoma. In the meantime, it’s at least reassuring to know that this often neglected mineral can enhance visual acuity by means that are currently unknown. (8)
I don’t often discuss the specifics of my own supplement regime. But I can tell you that I consistently include magnesium citrate and/or magnesium taurinate (magnesium bound to the amino acid taurine) in my daily routine. In addition, I consciously seek out magnesium-rich foods. Pumpkin seeds are perhaps my favorite dietary source of magnesium. In closing I want to mention that while magnesium is generally a very safe nutrient, it is not appropriate for those with compromised kidney function nor should it be taken with specific medications such as certain antibiotics, heart medications, and tranquilizers. Please consult your pharmacist and/or physician before beginning magnesium therapy if you think any of these issues pertain to you. (9)
Be well!
JP
Related Posts:
Tags: asthma, Bone and Joint Health, Pregnancy
Posted in Bone and Joint Health, Mental Health


February 23rd, 2010 at 4:01 am
Morning JP
great article! i think magnesium is still underrated. most people aren’t aware of that they are deficient in magnesium. Mg is one of my daily staples i can’t live without. Ok there are pumpkin seeds which have higher amounts but i don’t eat them every day. Years ago i had a very stressful time and i took mg after a cramp in my leg. I detected that Mg calmed me down in the evening - it was really relaxing for the mind and the whole body. Since then i know how necessary it is - for me.
I recommend to everyone to take Mg regularly. Never had any side effects.
Greetings
Nina K.
February 23rd, 2010 at 9:25 am
Great article. The list of magnesium benefits just seems to go on and on.
Pumpkin seeds are a great source (about 1mg magnesium per seed). However, there’s just so many one can eat in a day. Almonds pack in about 3mg per nut, so I mix them up.
A 5oz. halibut filet will have about 150mg. A hot cocoa, with plenty of real cocoa, is also well over 100mg.
And one cup of spinach is somewhere around 80mg.
I have also switched to San Pellegrino mineral water. It has 52mg of magnesium per bottle. Nobody else in my family likes the mineral taste, so I get it all to myself.
There was a study that indicated magnesium might be effective in delaying the onset of type II diabetes. In that case, only dietary magnesium was shown to be effective. Supplements did not have the same effect.
February 23rd, 2010 at 12:08 pm
Hello Pumpkin Seed!
San Pellegrino isn’t a good choice because this mineral water contains very high amounts of uranium ( http://foodwatch.de/foodwatch/content/e10/e2569/e13515/e27816/Uran-in-Mineralwasser_20090518_ger.pdf ) see page 35! The data given in the file are from official governmental offices in Germany.
In Europe mineral water must have limited amounts of that (below 2 mcg Uranium / l000 ml water) San Pellegrino is high above that amount ( about 5 - 8 mcg/l!) Uranium is very dangerous for the kidneys.
Greetings
Nina K.
February 23rd, 2010 at 1:54 pm
Nina,
Thank you for sharing your positive experience with magnesium and for the warning us about San Pellegrino.
Be well!
JP
February 23rd, 2010 at 1:57 pm
Pumpkin Seed,
I feel funny calling you that!
Thank you for your comments. I’m happy you stopped by and shared some additional magnesium info! Good stuff!
Be well!
JP
February 23rd, 2010 at 4:53 pm
Thanks JP! I try to take an additional magnesium capsule everyday. My Multi contains 8mg (oxide). Right now I’m using a Triple Magnesium Complex 400mg (oxide,citrate,aspartate).
My last bottle was Magnesium Malate. I’m thinking that may be more beneficial to an older person than the other forms. I was diagnosed with Osteopenia several years ago, and instead of increasing my Calcium intake like they suggested, I actually stopped taking Calcium supplements and started taking the Magnesium instead.
I don’t like the idea that Calcium may block the arteries, and I can’t always afford to have k2 on hand. I’d rather have a broken hip/leg than a major stroke!
k2c
February 23rd, 2010 at 5:03 pm
PS: I forgot to mention using Magnesium Oil transdermally for muscle tightness/cramps…works great!!
February 23rd, 2010 at 6:42 pm
Hi, JP and Nina
Ecchh..uranium (and I thought I had a healthy glow)
I used to export food to Europe, and I know their regulations can be a bit over the top, but I’ll have to look into that. Thanks.
February 23rd, 2010 at 10:17 pm
K2C,
Thank you! Magnesium malate has its pros and cons. It contains less elemental magnesium (than magnesium oxide) but it’s bioavailability is also greater. The malic acid component may also be useful in terms of promoting cellular energy. Magnesium malate is generally a bit more expensive as well. Ah, trade offs.
I’ll cover the topic of dietary calcium and arterial calcium deposits in a future blog. It’s an interesting point of discussion. Thanks for bringing that up!
PS - Good news about the topical magnesium helping with your muscle cramps!
Be well!
JP
February 24th, 2010 at 9:48 am
JP
The problem with the different forms of magnesium is the varying amount of elemental magnesium in the various types.
Mg oxide 60%
Mg citrate 16%
Mg orotate 7%
Mg amino acid chelate 18%
Peole switching from the usual Mg oxide to another form, should be aware that they may have to take a higher dosage to get the same amount of elemental magnesium.
February 24th, 2010 at 12:35 pm
Good Day JP!
Another Great Article! I take the Xtend life Multivitamin and it has Magnesium Citrate 200 mg. Wonder if that would be OK? I have read a lot of article on Magnesium and positive effects on Blood Pressure too! I will go chasing the pumpkin seeds today
Best regards
Sai.
February 24th, 2010 at 9:26 pm
Thank you for adding that, Liverock. A good point.
Personally, I would prefer to take 3 capsules of magnesium citrate instead of 1 capsule of magnesium oxide - even though they generally contain an equivalent amount of elemental mag.
Be well!
JP
February 24th, 2010 at 9:30 pm
Thank you, Sai!
That’s about half of the daily recommended intake for magnesium - according to the US RDA. I take quite a bit more than that. You might want to consider including some more magnesium rich foods (like pumpkin seeds) into your diet and/or adding a little bit more magnesium citrate to see what happens.
Be well!
JP
February 25th, 2010 at 12:23 am
JP, I’ll be looking forward to reading a calcium and artery blog in the future, should you decide to do it!
Liverock, thanks very much for the breakdown.
March 3rd, 2010 at 2:37 am
Great Article! Mg energizes me and helps disturbances in bladder control. I also think that the pumpkins seeds are the natural and cost-effective way to attain Mg in the body.